shmeen ([info]shmeen) wrote,
@ 2005-07-05 00:44:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Current mood: nerdy
Current music:The Drowning Man - The Cure

throwing arms around yesterday
There is something really traumatizing about horses that commit suicide or jump to their death. It's like a curse or something. A curse on the Calgary Stampede

I want to stop being so forgiving and resilient.  I want to be more angry and hold a grudge longer.  If people can give me some tips, it may help. 

I also had to give myself a few days before ranting about G8 End Poverty concerts that happened around the world.  I know it may seem kind of cynical to constantly complain when people are trying to do good things - and I have to admit it's the first time I saw the G8 in the news so much with so much criticism.  Remember when the G8 came to Calgary? Yeesh.  So, we can have Bob Geldof implore people to party it up and get hundreds of thousands of people in stadiums getting down on the G8. 

But what's fucked about it is the whole ending poverty in Africa is that there is no word about globalization and capitalism.  I mean, the G8 aren't a eight mean white guys.  Well, they are.  But they are countries that profit from poverty and prop up dictatorships and under-development in Africa. The nature of debt and structural adjustment is that others will profit from interest rates.  It isn't some mean attitude - it's the basis of capitalism.

I guess if we can get hundreds of thousands of jocks in the stadium listening to Metallica, it might be a good start to talk about it.  My guess is that it's all forgotten.  And I ain't expecting Bono or Madonna to have succint anti-capitalist and anti-racist analysis about it.  But it reeks of Live Aid - the whities helping the blackies.  And you can see this in the images of naked African children on tv that are supposed to drive compassion and charity.  But all these images do is cement racist structures in our minds - the West as the saviors for a problem that kills Africa and allows some of us to live in Western comfort.  We absolve high consumption by going to a stupid concert thinking Brian Adams is the step for self-determination in Africa.  I find it really interesting to see how the racial images of starving Africans is posited beside the West and how it shapes our consciousness. 

And god, did anyone else want to slit their throat when Madonna dragged Birhan Woldu around the stage singing "Like a Prayer?"  Claiming it was "us" that saved her? 

I understand that these campaigns will probably be more effective because it engages so many people (although it engages them with consumption).  But when its posited with savior vs victim, posits charity over self-determination, it can be so condescending. 




(Post a new comment)


(Anonymous)
2005-07-05 03:02 pm UTC (link)
hey! this is b's sister, the one with the "frankly my dear..." etc blog link on her site. i was just looking thru your entries and found it so weird how u're in Communications and live in Vancouver! Man that's my plan...except i call myself media queen and will go to vancouver after graduation. anyways cool journal :D

(Reply to this)


[info]ascentintochaos
2005-07-05 04:47 pm UTC (link)
I want to stop being so forgiving and resilient. I want to be more angry and hold a grudge longer. If people can give me some tips, it may help.
think about how fucked up people/the situation is. adopt a "it's all their fault! why can't they change?!" gripe and gripe and gripe over this. hold it in your heart. your chest. your stomach. until you feel sick.
i think that's the bad way of being angry and holding a grudge -- i think the key is to channel that anger productively, towards change and holding a grudge becomes knowing where they're at and where you're at and accepting it. (which isn't actually holding a grudge, i guess. :D )

anyway, i met you at rabfish's post green justice party! i was asking you about the vancover BRU. i'm lintil at the beets go on. :D thanks for linking us. i'm adding you as a friend, lemme know if it's a problem... when are you moving to smogtown (toronto)?

(Reply to this)

oh yeah and...
[info]ascentintochaos
2005-07-05 04:50 pm UTC (link)
did anyone else want to slit their throat when Madonna dragged Birhan Woldu around the stage singing "Like a Prayer?"
YES! i was flipping channels and i saw that and was like, ugh! reminded me of madonna's video when she's dancing around with black people or whatever -- doing the same thing with this individual, except live. didn't know who she was when i saw it but it'd be interesting to know her story in her own words rather than through the cbc. :D

(Reply to this)


[info]buildrebuild
2005-07-05 05:18 pm UTC (link)
fuck- bang on as usual sharmeen. when are you getting to calgary? i am looking forward to your visit!

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]shmeen
2005-07-07 01:17 am UTC (link)
dude - i have full time work at either Lunapads or Options for Sexual Health. So you might not see me until I drive through in AUgust, or if you move here earlier. Or we might just pass each other like two ships in the night. In either case, you have my heart. And we'll see each other soon. Promise.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]buildrebuild
2005-07-07 04:50 pm UTC (link)
gaaaah! that is too bad...we might be planning a fun weekend away at a friend's farm on a weekend that i thought you might be around...when will you be driving out? I think i will not be going out there until aug 18th or so....ships in the night indeed!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]rise_upp
2005-07-05 08:48 pm UTC (link)
what gets me is our demo in calgary got 200 people and theirs got 1.5 BILLION (capital letters on purpose).

(Reply to this) (Thread)

Boner for Bono
[info]shmeen
2005-07-07 01:19 am UTC (link)
It's cause we don't have Bono or Madonna on our side. Who can blame the Calgary masses? Who would you rather see - Coldplay? OR a bunch of radical cheerleaders in bad outfits? Seeing the thousands of people in the streets of Scotland is pretty cool, though.

(Reply to this) (Parent)

make poverty history campaign and critiques
[info]tracey23
2005-07-22 10:46 pm UTC (link)
i work on this Make Poverty History thing for a living and i have been conflicted about it for the past while.
sharmeen, i really appreciate your comments on it and your recognition that it's not ALL bad. in response, i would say that there are lots of us working on the campaign who recognize some of the major problems with rich white superstars "fighting" global poverty and the lack of analysis on the part of most of them. however, we are using the exposure they've given to the campaign to raise some issues. and at the campaign launch we had here there was much more talk about capitalism and globalization than i might have expected and i think we got a way bigger turn out to hear about those issues because of all the media exposure the campaign has gotten. SO...i don't know...i guess my point is just that there is SOME decent analysis coming from people within the campaign and that we are grateful for the critiques too...especially those that don't write off the whole thing completely.

(Reply to this) (Thread)

Re: make poverty history campaign and critiques
[info]shmeen
2005-07-22 11:58 pm UTC (link)
hey tracey,
i'm glad that we are livejournal friends! and i am glad you see that i meant no disrespect by the organizers. it's not so much the organizers, but the fixation of superstardom in our society where something is legitimized by rock stars. I don't trust Bono and hate how he legitimizes Paul Martin's policies. And I don't trust super super rich people speaking up about poverty. Their wealth is because other people are poor. But yeah...if it gets people talking about capitalism and globalization (with the irony that superstars are rich cause of capitalism), I am not begrudging that at all. But even with organizing locally, there is always a fixation to get someone really famous to legitimize different campaigns - and so a lot of time and effort is put into sucking up to rockstars - when i would rather the faces of the true agitators and organizers living in those effected communities.

I realize that this "ideal" will never be met given the context of our economies and cultures. And with the compromising and the "at least they are getting people to talk about stuff," I do feel it's positive. I just hope that the more challenging elements of what we envision as a new political structure or new economy doesn't get drowned out.

I think John Pilger's writing on this has been the best.

So yeah, congrats on the campaign work. Do you feel the campaign was successful with the outcomes of the G8 meeting? Geldof and Bono were happy, but from my sense, the demands weren't completely met, right?

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)

Re: make poverty history campaign and critiques
[info]tracey23
2005-07-24 09:28 pm UTC (link)
i'm really glad we're livejournal friends too!!! :) i REALLY like your journal. i just read a bunch of it and i like it a lot.
i think the outcome of the g8 meeting is better than it would have been without the campaign, but it obviously isn't enough, even for the reformist in me. :)

(Reply to this) (Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…